Apologies to KCRW's radio program "Left, Right & Center," but the question has been on the minds of our European friends since November 4: where does Barack Obama fit on the ideological spectrum?
On a Belgian TV talk show last Sunday, I tried to put him in The Center. Partly it was because there were both free market and socialist party representatives on the panel, both vying for the "we're closest to Obama" seat by categorizing him as either right or left of center.
The Socialist - a former minister who knows European trade union socialism and who would laugh at McCain-Palin attempts to paint Obama as a socialist or even a Marxist - knows that in the American firmament, the Democratic Party is about as left as it goes in the American mainstream. And that's not left enough for him.
The "liberal" official (in Europe, "liberal" translates best as "free market") was comforted by President-elect Obama's inclusion of lots of Wall Street financiers and assorted capitalists in his team of economic advisers, on display at his first press conference a few days prior. He too would snicker at the notion of Obama-as-Socialist.
Bill Clinton, in his rousing speech for Barack Obama in Florida days before the election, poured scorn on Republican attempts to create a "redistributionist" myth:
They just presided over the biggest redistribution of wealth upward since the 1920s and we all know how that ended. In the last eight years 90 percent of the gains went to 10 percent of the people over 40 percent to one percent. Can you run a great democracy that way? I don't think so. So don't tell me about redistribution.
But on TV last week, I insisted on situating Obama in the Center mainly because my Republican colleague was still fighting the election (we'd been in campaign debate mode so long it's no surprise that he had trouble adjusting to the new reality). Here are my sound bites:
- The Republicans, especially in the Bush era, brought America so far to the Right that now we have to tack Left to bring the ship of state back to the Center;
- When you're looking from extreme Right field, even the Center is to your Left.
These might sound cute rendered into French for TV or radio audiences, but do they describe the Obama reality? I consulted my wise Democrats Abroad Belgium colleague and fellow blogger, JP Bernbach, and tried out my "Centrist," even "Moderate" labels. To which JP replied, "Barack Obama is above all a Pragmatist."
Which I like, I must say. Americans are not really used to Left and Right, to the everlasting frustration of many on either wing. Many Americans despair over the supposed sameness (which I don't really buy) of Republican and Democratic Parties, and many foreigners have to search hard to situate the two main US parties on the political spectrum. A pragmatist, if that's what Obama is, searches for solutions to problems, and is less concerned with who has crafted the strategy than "can it work?"
Over the next weeks, the fight for Barack Obama's soul - well, maybe just his ear - will continue apace, between those who want him to hew a basically minimalist, business-as-usual course and those who want him to seize the historic moment and craft a new New Deal, 21st century-style.
So depending on your vantage point - from the Left, from the Right, or from overseas - when pondering how the future US president will govern, it should be comforting to most that he will do so from a "what works?" mind set. After years of ideological governance, principled pragmatism looks like a beautiful thing.